Can you manage your investments yourself instead of using an adviser?
Many people can manage investments themselves. The question is whether investing is the whole problem you are trying to solve.
Choose an adviser for your needs →
What does doing it yourself involve?
A self-directed investor chooses accounts, investments, risk level, contribution strategy and when to make changes. They also take responsibility for understanding the costs and tax treatment of the accounts they choose.
What can advice add?
An adviser can connect investments to retirement, spending, pensions, protection, inheritance or business decisions and make a personalised recommendation based on the wider position.
DIY may suit you if
It does not have to be all or nothing
Some consumers use one-off advice for a complicated decision and manage the implementation or investments themselves afterwards. Compare the service models before committing to ongoing fees.
List the responsibilities you would take on
Self-management means more than choosing an initial investment. You need to understand the purpose of the money, risk, diversification, charges, account rules and how to review changes. Administration and tax records can also become part of the work.
Ask whether you have the time and willingness to maintain that process when markets are unsettled or life becomes busy. Confidence during a rising market is not the same as a plan for dealing with losses or unexpected withdrawals.
Separate decisions you understand from those needing specialist assessment. You might manage a straightforward investment account yourself while seeking advice on a pension benefit, retirement income or another consequential issue.
Compare costs without assuming advice adds a guaranteed return
List platform, fund and transaction costs for the self-managed arrangement, then compare the adviser proposal's full cost and additional work. An adviser fee should not be assumed to purchase guaranteed outperformance.
For illustration, saving a fictional £1,500 annual advice charge does not remove underlying costs or the need to perform the tasks previously covered. The saving may be worthwhile if the service is unnecessary and you can manage the responsibility, but that needs an honest assessment.
If leaving an existing adviser, distinguish stopping advice from moving products. Check guarantees, exit costs and tax consequences before deciding that self-management requires a new provider.
Write a process you can follow
Record the goal, time horizon, acceptable risks, review dates and circumstances that would prompt another assessment. Avoid changing the plan solely in response to headlines without revisiting those assumptions.
Keep secure records and consider how someone with appropriate authority would manage the arrangement if you could not. Complexity can create an administration burden even when it initially feels interesting.
You can return for one-off advice or a second opinion when the question becomes more complex. Self-management and professional help are choices about responsibility that can change over time, rather than permanent identities you must defend.
Sources and further reading
MoneyHelper - Do I need a financial adviser? ↗
MoneyHelper: financial adviser fees ↗
